Bill Poteat
Ah, the romantic and nostalgic images conjured by thoughts of travel by passenger train.
Hurtling on a silver rail across a countryside that is always green, serene, and filled with one bucolic watercolor image of pastoral America after another.
Settling in at the dining car to a table topped with a red-checkered cloth, there to be served an eye-pleasing and sumptuous meal by hot and cold running waiters.
Taking the time to read, to chat, perhaps to doze until arriving promptly at your destination renewed, refreshed, and ready for adventure.
Ah, if only it were so. And perhaps in Germany, or Italy, or France such dreams might come close to reality.
But not so here in the United States. Here we are at the mercy of a slovenly beast called Amtrak. Before boarding the train, be sure to keep your expectations low so you can still be disappointed.
My daughter Jennifer and her Air Force captain husband Jordan lived in San Antonio for the last five years. During that time, in December of 2022, our precious granddaughter Margot Avery was born.
Earlier this summer, Jordan was transferred to Andrews Air Force Base in Washington, D.C., and the family now make their home across the Potomac in the suburban enclave of Alexandria, Va.
With my health a little uncertain this summer, bride Dinah and I decided to make our first journey north to visit by train rather than by car. The Carolinian pulls out of the station in Salisbury each morning at 7:30 and is scheduled to arrive in the Alexandria station, just 3 miles from my daughter’s home, at 4:30 p.m.
Eight and a half hours on a comfortable train versus a 420-mile drive that would likely stretch out to more than eight hours on busy interstate highways in the heat of August seemed a good idea.
The cost: roughly 200 bucks for each of us, round trip in business class. Not sure how that compares to airfare from Charlotte to Reagan National in Washington.
And now, for the experience.
THE GOOD
The drive from Morganton to the Salisbury station is an easy and simple one, taking roughly an hour and 20 minutes. Long-term parking at the station, which is safe, well-lighted, and quite beautiful, is free.
Business class seating is very comfortable with plenty of leg room, even for a long-shanked fella like me. Two seats on each side of the aisle. The seats recline for comfort and dozing. Two electric outlets are easily accessible.
The car in which we rode was comfortably cool. I was fine in short sleeves, but my bride required a sweater. Two restrooms were located at the end of the car, one of them handicapped accessible.
If you’re in no hurry, and trust me, you shouldn’t be, travel by train is about as stress free as it gets. Comfortable seat, constantly changing scenery, plenty of juice for your devices, and not one interstate accident or construction zone to deal with in a trip of more than 400 miles.
We rolled into the Alexandria station a little after 5 p.m. just a little more than an hour late. I groused a bit about that hour, not realizing that Amtrak considers any delay of an hour or less to be “on time.”
THE BAD
If you’re planning an all-day trip like we did, I would highly recommend you eat a good breakfast before arrival at the station, pack something light for lunch, and look forward to a great dinner at your destination.
The “dining car” on the Carolinian is more like a snack station. No checkered table clothes. No sumptuous choices of chicken, or fish, or beef. No wait staff. Just one harried woman behind a counter who failed her customer service class.
Your entrees include a microwaved cheeseburger or microwaved hot dog. I had one going and the other coming home and they both taste the same. Your choice of sides includes chips or chips. Bon appetit!
Business class passengers are entitled to as many free, non-alcoholic beverages as they want. The bride and I drank a lot of Diet Coke, ginger ale, and water. Anything involving alcohol was out of our price range.
Apparently at the pleasure of the harried woman behind the counter, “the cafe,” as they call it, can close for “break” at any time. And we’re not talking 15 or 20 minutes, we’re talking an hour and a half. Don’t bother to look for a schedule. One is not posted.
The harried woman who long ago forgot how to smile was not an exception among the Amtrak employees we encountered. Overall, they were a surly lot with little interest in customer service.
Perhaps Amtrak’s reputation has been so bad for so long that its employees no longer care one way or the other about dealing with customers in a friendly and professional manner.
THE UGLY
One thing any Amtrak customer should realize before climbing on board a train is that in America, freight trains are the priority with passenger trains little more than an afterthought.
Our aging system of track is built not for speed, but rather to carry the enormous weight of heavily loaded freight trains that can stretch for more than a mile from end to end.
On the American rails, freight trains are the bullies who dominate the playground while passenger trains spend the day getting sand kicked in their face.
Freight train coming? The Amtrak train will pull to the side. And wait. And wait. And wait.
Track in poor shape from the heavy volume of freight traffic? The Amtrak train will slow to a crawl. For mile after mile after mile.
Our return train was supposed to depart Alexandria at 11:30 a.m. and arrive back in Salisbury just as summer twilight was deepening, around 8 p.m.
At some point around mid morning, we received a text informing us the train would not depart Alexandria until 12:30. That would put us back in Salisbury about 9 p.m. Later than we had planned, but not horrible.
Soon after our son-in-law dropped us at the station, the departure time on the board shifted to 1 p.m. Then 1:20. The train actually pulled in at 1:40, two hours and 10 minutes late.
In our slow creep through Virginia, we did not make up for lost time. Instead, we lost even more time. There were two interminable waits for freights to pass. There were long stretches of moving 20 mph or less.
The sun set. The night darkened. The hours stretched toward midnight. And the ride went on and on and on.
The Carolinian pulled into the Salisbury station at 20 minutes before midnight, three hours and 40 minutes late. Exiting the train, I vowed that hell would freeze over before I would use Amtrak again.
We have a group in Burke County that wants to see Amtrak service instituted between Salisbury and Asheville, with a stop in Morganton. They call themselves “Waiting for the Train.”
A more appropriate name might be “Waiting, and Waiting, and Waiting, and Waiting for the Train.”




(0) comments
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.