The people who filled Morganton’s City Council chambers Wednesday morning weren’t looking for another explanation of why the City can’t solve its persistent odor problem.
Instead, they were looking for local leaders willing to fight for them.
The meeting itself didn’t hold much promise. Officials shared a detailed account of what the City had already done, what it can’t do, and why residents needed to keep pressing the North Carolina Division of Air Quality themselves. The City appeared to push much of the responsibility for finding a solution back on the residents.
Residents were asking a question that went largely unanswered: What is the City’s plan to get this problem solved?
The next day, however, the City of Morganton took ownership and shared an action plan in an email with members of Clear the Air Morganton, a group of residents who’ve banded together to finally get to the bottom of what is fouling the city’s air.
The plan listed four commitments.
- Council members will contact and enlist the help of Sen. Warren Daniel and Rep. Hugh Blackwell to press representatives from the Division of Air Quality to meet with council, staff, and residents.
- City staff will prepare a written staff report for inclusion in the Dec. 7 City Council agenda packet detailing the N.C. Department of Environmental Quality’s response and any additional updates available at the time.
- Anything requiring council action will be added to the Dec. 7 meeting agenda.
- City council will consider a resolution asking NCDEQ to investigate, report findings, and meet with the City and the Clear the Air Morganton group.
Morganton’s residents have been asking City leaders to publicly go to bat for them. Now, with this latest action plan, those leaders are coming out of the dugout.
This is an encouraging first step, one that could have happened much sooner.
During the meeting, City officials repeatedly explained that air-quality regulation is the state’s responsibility. City Manager Sally Sandy emphasized that Morganton lacks the personnel, expertise, and legal authority to conduct the kind of air-quality investigation residents are seeking.
But there is a considerable difference between lacking the authority to regulate air emissions and lacking the ability to advocate for the people who represent us.
City leaders can demand that the state investigate, enlist the help of state legislators, insist on regular communication from regulators, and keep the public informed about the progress of those efforts. That is what residents have been asking their city government to do.
When one resident asked what people could do if the City lacked the authority to act, Sandy replied, “I think we have to pressure DAQ to follow their process.”
When someone asked whose responsibility it was to bring state officials to the table, Sandy answered, “I would say it’s everybody’s job.”
Of course, residents have a role to play. But the suggestion that securing the state’s attention is everybody’s responsibility risks making it nobody’s responsibility.
The people of Morganton should not have to organize a petition, track down regulators, and coordinate a government response to an environmental problem while their elected leaders and City employees largely point them toward Raleigh.
That is precisely why they elect local officials in the first place: to represent their interests, amplify their concerns, and advocate on their behalf when solutions require the involvement of other levels of government.
Through Clear the Air Morganton, they have created a website to document odor incidents, organized and distributed complaints to state regulators, and gathered more than 900 petition signatures. They have attended council meetings, described how the smell affects their homes and businesses, and repeatedly asked for an investigation with clear responsibilities and deadlines.
The City should not simply tell residents to keep calling Raleigh. The problem isn’t their burden alone to bear.
To their credit, some council members acknowledged Wednesday that the City’s communication with residents had fallen short.
The promised Dec. 7 written report outlined in the action plan is a welcome improvement. The City should make that report the beginning of a regular practice of keeping residents informed.
The plan says items will be added to the council’s agenda as information becomes available requiring council action. That leaves no stated schedule for public updates when there is no action for council to take. Residents need to hear whether state officials have responded, whether a meeting has been scheduled, what questions remain unanswered, and what the city intends to do next. A lack of progress is itself something the public deserves to know.
That is why a standing agenda item remains a reasonable request. The public deserves an update even when no council action is required.
What important element is still missing? A point person at the city responsible for spearheading the solution.
The city should publicly designate someone responsible for coordinating with DEQ. If DEQ declines to participate or fails to respond, the City should say so publicly and explain what it intends to do next.
None of those steps requires Morganton to become an air-quality regulator. They require its elected officials to act as advocates.
Morganton officials need not presume that Case Farms, the City’s wastewater system, or any other potential source is responsible. In fact, they shouldn’t. But they should be willing to put the full influence of City government behind finding out.
Now is the time for their elected representatives to step up to the plate.
The City should not be content to explain whose job it isn’t. It should be determined to make sure somebody gets the job done, and keep the public informed every step of the way.


(0) comments
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.