The first hard frosts and frozen mornings signal it. The newly taped Turkey Trot 5K flyers in downtown windows are proof of it. Just don’t look at the calendar: Thanksgiving is closer than it appears!
The Thanksgiving table is one of the hardest to pair with wine. There are so many complementary and contrasting flavors and textures. There are so many people with firm opinions about wines they like and definitely don’t like. And then the questions of which wine with which courses. It can all quickly feel a little too much.
Fear not; I’m here to help. Whether you’re hosting a traditional Thanksgiving or heading to a potluck Friendsgiving, the wines in my holiday guide for 2026 will not disappoint.
Before we get into the wines, I want to give you permission to make service really easy on yourself and your guests. You know it; I know it. There’s going to be too much to do. No matter how many times you double check your timeline, time will be precious. And there’s not going to be enough space to do it all, even if you’ve hidden all your kitchen clutter in the back closet.
Here’s what I do: Put the wines on the table, open them, say a few words about why you like them (if you must). Open wine bottles and no pretense are an invitation for guests to choose. Some guests might want a sample of each. Others will see a grape variety or region with which they’re familiar and lean into comfort. No one will feel pressure to drink something they think they’re not going to like. If you use some wines from this list, you can even use my notes and invite your guests to read up while you’re checking the temp on the turkey.
A quick primer on food and wine pairings, what works and what doesn’t work, before you head to the wine shop with your trusty guide in hand. Try not to worry too much about matching flavors in the wines with flavors in the food. It’s nearly always the case that structures make or break a pairing. And the Thanksgiving table is a particular minefield for contrasting flavors. For this meal, we want to really focus on structures.
High acid wines will be very friendly with high acid foods: When you pair high food acidity with high acid in wine, the wine’s fruit profile comes out even more and its acid goes to the background. Almost all wines will benefit from food saltiness — the salt in food pulls forward the fruit profile of the wine. Foods with coating fats (think gravies and luscious meats pulled from the oven, dripping with interstitial fat) will benefit and experience lift from the cutting acid in wine. Sweetness in food is wine’s worst enemy.
All of the wines are available in Morganton, either right now or within a week of asking for special delivery. Tell them John sent you!
Maison Chavet Pouilly-Fume 2025: Don’t think about this one. Just buy it. It’s currently my wine of the year for 2026, and there’s nothing on the horizon to knock it from its perch. This stunner is from the Loire Valley in France. You’ve likely never heard of Pouilly-Fume, but you’ve definitely heard of the village just on the other side of the river: Sancerre. Same grape: Sauvignon Blanc. Same winemaking style. Same profile (just add a little more flintiness and stoniness). But it’s always substantially less expensive than Sancerre — and that’s only because of name recognition.
This wine is high acid and really angular on the palate. It’s so food-friendly. There are notes of grapefruit, passion fruit, florality, a few green notes of bell pepper, and grassiness. If you only buy one wine from the list, it should be this one. A stunner! Both Craft’d and Food Matters are routinely stocking it now. You’re welcome.
Hermann J. Wiemer Flower Day Riesling 2024: You’ll need to run to Craft’d to find this wine. Laura bought in a case, and I’ve already relieved her of two bottles. Grown in a biodynamic-certified vineyard in the Finger Lakes, this wine is one of my very favorite bottles.
When I tasted it the first time at the winery, I was immediately in love. I remember my tasting note: This wine is Grace Kelly in a glass. Stylish, elegant, very serious stuff. Tremendously good acidity for your Thanksgiving table. And listen, we all need to stop judging Riesling on the sweet stuff the market has fooled us into believing all Riesling is. If you’ve never had a bone-dry Riesling, well, here’s your chance to rid yourself of those silly thoughts. Race ya to Craft’d? I’m a pretty fast runner. 3, 2, 1: GO.
Forge Caywood Chardonnay 2024 (or 2022!): Another suggestion from New York’s Finger Lakes. I think the Chardonnays that Leana is making at Forge might just be the most exciting Chardonnay in the United States. It’s lean and high acid like Chablis. But those 50-plus-year-old vines build tension and structure in the wines that let them swell in your mouth — think about how a sourdough loaf with good tension and gluten musculature swells in the oven.
At around 12.5%, the wines impress with uncommon concentration. They end up having Chablisian angularity simultaneously with Puligny Montrachet tension and structure. They’re pure heaven for me — the kind of Chardonnay I like to drink. And all that acid will make them perfect for your table. And your guests will likely not have had Chardonnay in this style.
Microcosmico Garnacha: Don’t think. Just go to Food Matters and grab a few bottles of the Microcosmico Garnacha, made by Master of Wine Fernando Mora. Your pocketbook will thank me later. This wine is a model for the new style of Garnacha coming out of Spain, and the rest of the world is just starting to follow suit in this Grenaissance (Garnacha + Renaissance).
You’ve likely had Grenache, even if you don’t remember it. It’s the principal grape in Southern Rhone blends (Chateauneuf du Pape, Cotes du Rhone, etc). But those wines are not like this. The Spanish have proved that when we pick Grenache/Garnacha early, it has great acidity, buoyant textures, bright red fruits, and alcohol levels that don’t beat us up. I absolutely adore this wine. 12.5%! It almost tingles. I am already thinking about this wine with a perfect forkful of turkey and gravy pushed into a pile of mashed potatoes and, importantly, a little cranberry sauce. If I were going to put one red wine on my table, it would be this.
Cool(ish) Climate Pinot Noirs: There are too many good examples to toss at you, so I’m going to give you several to choose from if you’re not into the Garnacha. For me, the most food-friendly red for Thanksgiving is Pinot. It’s got plenty of acidity and not so much tannin. The ones I’ll recommend are red-fruited, buoyant, and I’d be happy with any of them if you handed me a glass. Craft’d either has all of these on hand or can special order: The River Farm Pinot from New Zealand is Old World in aspiration but pocketbook friendly. Bright red fruits with a strong savory core. And you’ll impress your friends by knowing that New Zealand makes something other than Sauvignon Blanc.
For your pals who like bigger versions of Pinot that still have food-friendly acidity, reach for the D’Alfonso-Curran from Santa Barbara. Bruno lets the grapes hang for a really long time–more sugar gives more alcohol, and longer hang times give riper fruits.
Ready to splurge? Reach for the Burgundy or the Burgundy-inspired. One of my all-time favorite producers, Domaine Pierre Gelin, is at Craft’d with his absolutely stunning Fixin (pronounced fee-SAHN, no enunciating the n, just drop your jaw). It’s structured, red and black fruits, loads of acid. Plenty of fruitiness but a distinctive savory core. Your friends will thank you; the food will appreciate showing off with it.
And if you can find a bottle of the cultish Domaine Nicolas-Jay, a relatively new project in Oregon’s Willamette Valley co-founded with the folks from Burgundy’s Meo-Camuzet, you’ll be drinking what the cool kids are drinking. Candidly, it’s hard to find and in short supply, but I’ve spied a few bottles left. Go!
When it’s time for dessert, there’s only one sweet wine to reach for — the Petit Metris Coteaux du Layon Chaume 1er Cru, available at Craft’d. It’s a quarter of the price of a full bottle of Sauternes but made the exact same way, just with botrytized Chenin Blanc. Even people who claim not to like sweet wine will finish their glass!
John Zimmerman earned the distinguished WSET Diploma with Merit in 2022, owns a WSET wine school in Morganton that offers WSET Levels 1-3 and in-house courses, and teaches wine locally and across North Carolina. John can be contacted for all things wine at www.ourdailywine.wine and john@ourdailywine.wine.
Success! An email has been sent to with a link to confirm list signup.
Error! There was an error processing your request.
Sorry, an error occurred.
Already Subscribed!
Cancel anytime
Thank you .
Your account has been registered, and you are now logged in.
Check your email for details.
Submitting this form below will send a message to your email with a link to change your password.
An email message containing instructions on how to reset your password has been sent to the email address listed on your account.
No promotional rates found.
Secure & Encrypted
Thank you.
Your gift purchase was successful! Your purchase was successful, and you are now logged in.
| Rate: | |
| Begins: | |
| Transaction ID: |
A receipt was sent to your email.
(0) comments
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.