A federal judge ruled in favor of Morganton-based high-end furniture manufacturer E.J. Victor Inc., allowing the company to seek $75,000 in damages from Fireman’s Fund Insurance Co. The ruling, issued by U.S. District Judge Martin Reidinger, determined that the insurance policy's exception for damage from "named storms" like Hurricane Helene exempts E.J. Victor from the flood damage exclusion. E.J. Victor had filed a complaint against the insurance company for denying coverage following significant damage to its facility, resulting in the unfortunate permanent layoff of 121 employees. The company is represented by King & Spalding LLP, while Fireman’s Fund is represented by Troutman Pepper Locke LLP and Moore & Van Allen PLLC.
Five Morganton city leaders are seeking to dismiss a civil lawsuit brought against them by Bella Vino owner Emmanuel Manolakas, alleging defamation, unfair business practices, malicious prosecution, and abuse of legal processes.
In the aftermath of the Bella Vino trial, the City of Morganton, with the assistance of newly appointed attorney Daniel E. Peterson, is challenging the $705,000 verdict through various motions. The City, represented by Peterson and Andrew Santaniello, has filed motions seeking a new trial, judgment alteration, and relief, citing concerns over flawed jury instructions and speculative damages. The dispute centers around a breach of contract claim against owner Emmanuel Manolakas, with the City requesting a reduction in the award or a new trial to address perceived issues. The upcoming motion hearing on July 16 at the Burke County Courthouse will further examine the City's efforts to challenge the jury's decision and potentially mitigate post-judgment interest.