Morganton city officials disappointed residents who packed the council chambers Wednesday, hoping to hear how their elected leaders planned to address the sulfur-like odor that has plagued downtown.
They didn’t get an answer that day.
However, just over 24 hours later, the City provided an action plan, detailing the steps it planned to take through Thanksgiving and what it intended to have prepared in time for the next City Council meeting on Dec. 7.
During the meeting, members of Morganton City Council, City Manager Sally Sandy, and several city employees explained that staff had investigated the odor, and finding nothing conclusive so far, delegated the remainder of the work and regulatory oversight to the North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality.
![]()
Morganton City Manager Sally Sandy (left) explains steps that
staff have taken in response to residents’ complaints about an
unidentified stench that regularly floats into and around downtown
Morganton. Beside her is Councilmember Molly McKay.
JACOB CHRISTOPHER / THE PAPER
“We cannot solve an odor issue,” Sandy said. “We need DAQ at the table to figure out what is required to do that and to manage that process. They are the entity that has that responsibility and that authority and that skillset. I think it’s important that you (the residents) continue to ask them to do that.”
The action plan states that council members will contact state Sen. Warren Daniel and state Rep. Hugh Blackwell to help arrange a meeting with the N.C. Division of Air Quality (DAQ). The goal is to better understand how the agency investigates odor complaints and what its investigations have revealed, information Sandy said during the meeting has been difficult to obtain.
Furthermore, by Dec. 7, Morganton will prepare a written staff report for the agenda packet regarding the response and other updates. The council will also consider a resolution requesting DAQ to investigate, report the findings, and meet with the City and Clear the Air Morganton, whose online petition and reporting tool prompted the meeting.
INSPECTIONS OFFER NO ANSWERS
The conversation took place in the City Council chambers, with members of the council and representatives from Clear the Air Morganton sitting at a U-shaped table, with the audience surrounding the discussion, commenting as the meeting went on.
The topic of the sulfur-like odor has grown in recent months, spawning a community-led petition from Clear the Air Morganton which has gained more than 930 signatures and a series of resident reports over several weeks — even prompting a resolution adopted by the Burke County Commissioners to request a formal investigation from the DAQ.
Organizers of Clear the Air Morganton asked the City to identify the next steps, appoint someone to take responsibility for the process, and provide a timeline for actionable steps.
Mayor Pro-tem Wendy Cato told the attendees — nearly 40 residents filling the seats and standing along the walls — that the investigation had started following public comments in October, and that the Council apologized for not being more communicative earlier in the process.
She said the investigation is ongoing.
No sources were found in the wastewater lines, said Water Resources Director Randy Smith, detailing the various investigative steps Morganton’s taken at manholes and other possible sources, checking for hydrogen sulfide and other noxious smells or indicators.
![]()
Water Resources Director Randy Smith explained that city
employees have been ‘popping manholes and doing a visual inspection
of the condition.’
JACOB CHRISTOPHER / THE PAPER
Smith said his team checked the sewer lines leading up to Case Farms — where many residents believe the odor originates from — when the facility was closed, “popping manholes and doing a visual inspection of the condition.”
The stormwater drains aren’t culprits either, said Stormwater Administrator Tom Warburton. Between his employees and public works employees, they haven’t found standing water, illicit discharges, or any dead animals that they could source the smell to.
CITY SAYS AUTHORITY IS LIMITED
Morganton’s ordinances cover noxious smells which are “sufficient to create a public nuisance.” However, City Attorney Keith Rigsby explained that it wasn’t as simple as citing an entity for an ordinance violation.
Since the responsibility for odors falls to the state, if Morganton “implements measures which could be seen as measures a state agency should implement, then we’re in violation of state law,” said Rigsby.
Warburton weighed in, explaining that the foul odor ordinance provides a process for residents to file complaints, which prompts the city to investigate and target factors within its control, such as trash pile-up, illicit discharge, or having too many animals.
“We can attack the source, if we find it,” Warburton explained. “If we don’t, there’s just a foul odor, then DAQ is then called to monitor it, because we don’t have those benchmarks.”
WHAT’S NEXT?
The City Council told members of Clear the Air Morganton that it would begin development on an action plan, touching base soon to lay out the details.
Sandy said the responsibility for remedying the odors fell to the state, but the City did not invite DAQ to the Wednesday discussion.
Clear the Air Morganton representatives confirmed that they spotted DEQ Air Quality Regional Supervisor Michael Koerschner and a couple other DEQ reps in the crowd, although they didn’t speak.
“I don’t know that our local tax dollars ought to be spent to (hire outside consultants), when you’ve paid your state tax dollars and this is DEQ’s responsibility,” Sandy said. “Obviously, the council gets to decide what they want to do. … Is an engineer hired by us where we don’t have authority necessarily to do some things on private property, is that an answer? DEQ has that authority.”
Sandy did say, however, that Case Farms was made aware of the meeting, but no representatives spoke, and no one was identifiable in the crowd as a rep from the facility.
RESIDENT REACTIONS
Larry Cole, a resident of Burkemont Avenue, wasn’t satisfied with the outcome of the meeting, explaining that he felt the City avoided a definitive explanation.
He said that since the smell started garnering more attention, he believes it has improved.
“I’m hearing the stormwater guys, they’re talking about dead animals and sewer treatment plants. This is not about any of that,” Cole said. “This is about what’s coming straight off of Rand Street. We all know where it’s coming from. I feel like the city’s just taking — the city manager said she didn’t want to say where the smell was coming from. I don’t know what their deal is.”
Case Farm chicken processing facility is located at 121 Rand St.
Betsy Chalfin, a Morganton resident and self-proclaimed night owl, explained that the smell hasn’t dissipated, but changed times to the middle of the night and occasionally in the afternoon.
Chalfin would like to see the City take a more assertive role in requesting investigations from the DAQ and narrowing down the true source of the odors.
“The smell is incredibly unpleasant, but it’s also anxiety-producing in terms of what it’s doing to people’s health, especially the people who work at Case Farms,” she said. “If it’s not Case Farms, then great. Let’s find out what it is. We need to bring in some serious agency to really investigate instead of just pussyfooting around.”